Submit a Story!
We never said biochar is a miracle cure
George Monbiot's implication that we believe biochar is a miracle solution to CO2 reduction is grossly misunderstood It is unfortunate that George Monbiot has insinuated that one of us (Jim Hansen) is a believer in biochar as a "miracle" solution for the climate crisis . If he is basing this ...
James Lovelock on Biochar: let the Earth remove CO2 for us | Environment
guardian.co.uk — I usually agree with George Monbiot and love the way he says it but this time –... with his assertion that the latest miracle mass fuel cure, biochar, does not stand up – he has got it only half right. Yes, it is silly to rename charcoal as biochar and ... (more) James Lovelock on Biochar: let the Earth remove CO2 for ...
Chris Goodall responds to George Monbiot on biochar | 				Environment
Chris Goodall responds to George Monbiot on biochar | Environment
guardian.co.uk — A seedling grown in a potting mixture including Biochar. Photograph: www.biochar-international.org A seedling grown in a potting... mixture including Biochar. Photograph: www.biochar-international.org (more) Chris Goodall responds to George Monbiot on biochar ...
This gift of nature is the best way to save us from climate catastrophe
guardian.co.uk — Biochar schemes would remove carbon from the atmosphere and increase food supply, says Peter Read I believe... that George Monbiot, in rubbishing the concept of biochar, misrepresents my work ( Woodchips with everything. It's the Atkins plan of the ... (more) This gift of nature is the best way to save us from ...
Comments
Blog Reactions

Biochar is No Climate Change Miracle Cure: George Monbiot
TreeHugger — ... agriculture into charcoal and bury it. Consider grain like wheat or rice; most of the plant mass is in the stems, stalks and roots and we only eat the seeds. So instead of just ploughing in the stalks or turning them into cardboard, make it into charcoal and bury it or sink it in the ocean. We don't need plantations or crops planted for biochar, what we need is a charcoal maker on every farm so the farmer can turn his waste into carbon. Hansen: We Never Said Biochar Was Miracle Cure Hansen's response was equally clear, Although we do mention waste-derived biochar as a possible ...

Jim Hansen on Biochar!!
arduous blog — More from The Guardian's pages on biochar! Also, if you want to read Hansen's full report, go to. I am not going to read it because I have thousands and thousands of other reports that I have to procrastinate reading first. But if one of you pretty readers would like to read it, and then summarize said report, I and everyone else will ... tell you that you are pretty? And kewl? By the way, if you don't read The Guardian's environment section, I really, really recommend it. ...

Pyrolising the Planet
Monbiot.com — The debate over biochar hots up. By George Monbiot. Published on my Guardian blog, 27th March 2009 Well that got ‘em going. So far James Lovelock , Jim Hansen and Pushker Kharecha , Chris Goodall and Peter Read have all responded in the Guardian to my column on biochar. Reading their responses, I realise that it was unfair of me to include James Lovelock and Jim Hansen on the list of those who have been suckered by the charleaders. Their position is more nuanced than I made out. Chris Goodall, to his credit, has accepted that he was too bullish about ...

Pyrolising the Planet
Permaculture Research Institute of Australia — Pyrolising the Planet Biodiversity , Deforestation , Food Shortages , Global Warming/Climate Change , Soil Erosion & Contamination — by George Monbiot The debate over biochar hots up. by George Monbiot - journalist, author, academic and environmental and political activist [image] Well that got ‘em going. So far James Lovelock , Jim Hansen and Pushker Kharecha , Chris Goodall and Peter Read have all responded in the Guardian to my column on biochar . Reading their responses, I ...

Renewables & biofuels - Apr 1
Energy Bulletin - — ... in the UK Guardian on March 24, 2009 that questioned the validity of biochar as a climate mitigation tool and the scientists and others who support the development of biochar. The Guardian has published responses from several of those biochar supporters mentioned by Mr. Monbiot, including James Hansen , ...

The Biochar Question–Part I
FUTURISM NOW — ... of Monbiot’s recent Guardian column.  He’s been writing lately about what he sees as an over-dependence on the idea of using biochar to soak up CO2. “Charleaders must cool enthusiasm for setting fire to the planet Reactions to my ‘biochar’ stance got a lot of people fired up, but I was too soft on one champion of so-called development. (March 27 2009) — “Well that got ‘em going. So far James Lovelock, Jim Hansen and Pushker Kharecha, Chris Goodall and Peter Read have all responded ...

Turning Charcoal Into Carbon Gold
Worldchanging: Bright Green — ... storage. Carbon, in the form of wood from trees and agricultural waste, can be turned to charcoal and buried in the ground, so storing it away from the atmosphere. If enough carbon can be buried in this way, then it could bolster so-far feeble global attempts to address climate change through cuts greenhouse gas emissions. Making and burying biochar to help reduce carbon levels in the atmosphere has some heavy green backing, including scientist and author James Lovelock and Jim Hansen of Nasa. The journal Nature Reports Climate Change said that biochar " could be ...

Related Content
Correspondence with Ian Plimer
monbiot.com 9/16/2009 — Here are the emails I’ve exchanged with the climate change denier Ian Plimer.
How Much Should We Leave in the Ground?
monbiot.com 5/7/2009 — Here are some estimates for how much fossil fuel we can use, and a call for a global moratorium on new prospecting.
Ian Plimer’s questions to George Monbiot
chriscolose.wordpress.com 8/24/2009 — Hopefully people interested in the blog wars have been alerted to the ongoing “debate” between George Monbiot and Ian Plimer. If not, the best place to start is probably Monbiot’s blog itself (with several posts on the topic ...
The Race Toward a Climate Change Cure
time.com 2/20/2009 — Trying to predict the world's climate a century from now is an inexact science . The most recent assessment by the U.N. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) estimates that global temperatures could rise between 2 and 11.5 degrees F during ...
Not Even Wrong
monbiot.com 9/1/2009 — We need a radical new approach to cutting greenhouse gases, and it might have arrived.
Ten big green ideas from the Geneva Motor Show
guardian.co.uk 3/4/2009 — Car makers may be in trouble, but that's not stopping them rolling out new green ideas at the Geneva Motor Show, writes motoring journalist Richard Aucock 1. GM hasn't killed the electric car In 2006, a documentary film Called Who Killed the ...
Apartment Therapy The Kitchn | Kitchen Cure Weekend Report: How Did It Go? The Kitchen Cure Spring 2009 - Week 3
thekitchn.com 5/5/2009 — 2009_05_03-Flowers.jpg 4-2-kitchncure.gif Week 3 Assignment : Deep cleaning, special projects, and beautify! Cure Clock: 3 weeks remaining (halfway done!) Cure Takers: 831 Good morning, Cure-takers! How was this past weekend, and did it help you move ...
Why clean coal is years away
usnews.com 3/19/2009 — U.S. News and World Report: America runs on coal. It's cheap, plentiful (at least for another 100 years or so), and comfortingly domestic. Two hundred years ago, it powered the industrial revolution. Today, it spits out nearly half of the country's ...
Plimer’s homework assignment
realclimate.org 8/28/2009 — Some of you may be aware of George Monbiot’s so-far-unsuccessful attempt to pin down Ian Plimer on his ridiculous compendium of non-science . In response to Monbiot’s request for explanation and sources for some of Plimer’s more ...
Climate chaos, indeed
theenergycollective.com 6/23/2009 — We are continually faced with a series of great opportunities brilliantly disguised as insoluble problems. – John W. Gardner The quote above came to mind when I read ‘Worst Case’ Scenario: New Report Says World Is Warming Faster than Thought : Two degrees — that value has long been ...
Drilling the Arctic for Energy: Does tapping Alaskan oil to increase energy independence come at our peril?Scientific American - Environment 3/25/2009
On a day marking the 20th anniversary of the notorious Exxon Valdez oil spill, environmentalists urged lawmakers to reinstate a ban on new offshore drilling for oil and gas in vast expanses of the outer continental shelf--the land that extends off of ...
Scott Paul: Don't Leave China Out of the Climate DebateGreen on HuffingtonPost.com 3/25/2009
China's pollution costs lives, warms the planet, and distorts trade. It also harms American jobs. Unless the damage caused by China's pollution is addressed, the debates on climate change and global trade will inevitably get sidetracked and ...
A veritable flood of climate and energy bills in CongressGrist - the Latest from Grist 3/25/2009
There’s been a deluge of bills on climate and energy introduced in Congress in the past few weeks.    
The New Yorker (!) parrots right-wing talking points on climateGrist - the Latest from Grist 3/25/2009
The New Yorker magazine has just published a lead story on climate, “ Economy vs. Environment ,” by David Owen, that is so bad, so filled with long-debunked right-wing talking points, it would barely qualify for the Wall Street Journal ...